Episode 69 – Ty Olsson
Grab your favorite salt rounds and a flask of vampire blood, Conundrum Crew — because this week, Jeremy and Traci sit down with the legendary Ty Olsson! You know...
Episode 68 – Bridging Worlds: Rob Gutro on Spirits, Pets & the Afterlife
In this chilling and heartwarming episode of Total Conundrum, Jeremy and Traci welcome Rob Gutro — medium, paranormal researcher, and author of several books on spirits and the afterlife....
Episode 67 – The Roff House Gets Conundrum’d, TWATTED, and Screamed At
In this extra-special crossover, we’re teaming up with T.W.A.T.S. (The Wisconsin Apparition Tracking Society) and our paranormal podcast friends over at I Scream You Scream to bring you a...
Episode 66 – Worlds Most Haunted Island
This week, we’re teaming up with our creepy-cool neighbor from Wisconsin — Star from Creepy Shit Podcast! She’s joining us to share her favorite kind of nightmare fuel: the...
Episode 65 – Locked Up, Lost Souls: The Secrets & Spirits of Alcatraz
What do Al Capone’s ghost, a raincoat raft, and a haunted prison hospital have in common? They’re all part of the chilling history of Alcatraz—“The Rock.” Join Traci &...
Episode 64 – Sealed in Tragedy: The Chicago Tylenol Murders
In 1982, a wave of terror swept across Chicago—not with a gun or a knife, but with something found in nearly every medicine cabinet: Tylenol. In this emotionally charged...
Episode 63 – Ghosts, Gadgets, and the Midwest: Chatting with Dave from Midwest Spirit Seekers
Join us as we talk with Dave from Midwest Spirit Seekers — one of the most passionate and experienced paranormal investigators in the Midwest! In this episode, we explore...
Episode 62 – The Van Meter Visitor: Iowa’s Winged Nightmare
In 1903, the quiet little town of Van Meter, Iowa, got a visit from something strange — an eight-foot, bat-winged, bulletproof, sulfur-smelling nightmare with a glowing horn. And no,...
Episode 61 – The Unsolved Murder of Missy Bevers: A Chilling Case of Deception and Mystery
Description: Before dawn on April 18, 2016, fitness instructor and devoted mother of three, Missy Bevers, arrived at Creekside Church of Christ in Midlothian, Texas, ready to lead her...
Episode 60 – The Ariel School UFO Encounter: 60 Kids, One Unforgettable Day in Zimbabwe
Description: September 16, 1994 — Ruwa, Zimbabwe. Sixty-two schoolchildren ran screaming across the playground, claiming they had just seen something that would haunt them for the rest of their...
Episode 59 – Carroll Edward Cole: The 8 Year Old Serial Killer
He was just eight years old when he killed for the first time… and no one noticed. In this episode of Total Conundrum, Jeremy and Traci unravel the disturbing...
Episode 58 – The Roff House Possession Case: America’s First Documented Spirit Takeover
In this chilling deep dive, Jeremy and Traci unravel one of America’s strangest and most documented cases of spirit possession: the story of Lurancy Vennum and Mary Roff, known...
Episode 57 – Bonus Ed Gein: The Butcher of Plainfield | Total Conundrum x Dairyland Frights
Episode Title: The Butcher of Plainfield: Ed Gein’s Twisted Legacy – with John from Dairyland Frights Episode Description: This week on Total Conundrum, we’re digging up one of the...
Episode 56 – Wanted for 18 Years: Unmasking John List
He left the lights on, the radio playing hymns, and walked out of his New Jersey mansion like nothing happened. But inside that house? A scene so disturbing it...
Episode 55 – The Haunting of Fox Hollow Farm | Serial Killer Meets Haunted House
What happens when a suburban dad turns serial killer… and his house refuses to forget? Welcome to Fox Hollow Farm — part true crime, part paranormal nightmare. In this...
Episode 54 – THE BELL WITCH – AMERICA’S MOST TERRIFYING HAUNTING
A ghost that talks. A curse that kills. A legend that refuses to die. In this episode, we dive deep into the terrifying true story of the Bell Witch—the...
Episode 53 – Cry Little Sister No More: G Tom Mac Unplugged & Unfiltered
“Vampire Anthems & Rock Operas with G Tom Mac” 🔊 Episode Summary: In this electrifying episode of Total Conundrum, we’re joined by the legendary G Tom Mac—the voice, the...
Episode 52 – The Lost Boy: Jamison Newlander Talks Blood, Bites & Behind-the-Scenes
Total Conundrum x Jamison Newlander: The Frog Brother Files 🧛♂️ Episode Summary: This week, we sit down with the iconic Jamison Newlander, better known as Alan Frog from the...
Episode 51 – Sarah Goode: A Night Out Turned Nightmare
Episode Description: In the quiet town of Medford, New York, 21-year-old Sarah Goode was a devoted young mother, full of laughter, promise, and love. When she disappeared after a...
Episode 50 – Island of the Dolls
Episode Description: Deep in the ancient canals of Xochimilco, Mexico, lies a place unlike any other. Trees filled with hundreds—if not thousands—of decaying, glassy-eyed dolls sway in the breeze....
Episode 49 – The Denver Spiderman: Theodore Edward Coneys’ Secret Life of Horror
📍 Episode Description: You’ve heard of Spider-Man—but this isn’t a story about a hero. This is the disturbing true tale of Theodore Edward Coneys, a man who became known...
Episode 48 – Waverly Hills Sanatorium: The Most Haunted Place in America
📍 Episode Description: Step inside the decaying halls of Waverly Hills Sanatorium, one of the most infamous haunted locations in America. From its origins as a state-of-the-art tuberculosis hospital...
Episode 47 – Harold Shipman: The Doctor of Death
Harold Shipman: The Doctor of Death 📍 Episode Description: He took an oath to heal—but instead, he became one of the most prolific serial killers in history. In this...
Episode 46 – Haunted History of Trevena Castle
The Haunting of Trevena Castle 📍 Episode Description: A castle on the edge of the sea… a family desperate for peace… and a darkness that refused to stay buried....
Episode 45 – Inside the Mind of Jeffrey Dahmer The Milwaukee Cannibal
📍 Episode Description: Step into the chilling mind of one of America’s most notorious serial killers—Jeffrey Dahmer. A man whose gruesome crimes shocked the world, Dahmer lured victims into...
Winchester Mystery House: Cursed Mansion or Haunted Legend
Step into one of the most mysterious and haunted locations in America—the Winchester Mystery House. A mansion built under the guidance of spirits, with doors leading to nowhere, staircases...
Episode 43 – Ed Gein: The Killer Who Inspired Hollywood’s Most Terrifying Villains
📍 Episode Description: Step into one of the most horrifying true crime stories in history as we uncover the twisted life and crimes of Ed Gein—the grave robber and...
Episode – 42 Bobby Mackey’s: The Most Haunted Nightclub in America
🎶👻 New Episode Alert: The Haunting of Bobby Mackey’s Music World! 👻🎶 Welcome to the most haunted honky-tonk in America—where the music plays, the whiskey flows, and the spirits?...
Episode 41 – Ted Bundy – Story of a Murderer
🚨 New Episode Alert! 🚨 This week on Total Conundrum, we’re diving into the chilling, twisted mind of Ted Bundy—one of America’s most notorious serial killers. From his charming...
Episode 40 – Haunted History of Tonopah
Total Conundrum Podcast – Show Notes Episode Title: The Haunted History of Tonopah Episode Description: Welcome to Total Conundrum, where we explore the weird, the eerie, and the downright...
Episode 39 – John Wayne Gacy – The Killer Clown
Welcome to Total Conundrum, where we delve deep into the darkest corners of true crime history. In today’s episode, we’re exploring the horrifying legacy of John Wayne Gacy, also...
Episode 38 – The Manson Family Murders: A Nightmare in Hollywood
Welcome to Total Conundrum, where we peel back the layers of the most chilling true crime stories. Today, we’re diving deep into the twisted world of Charles Manson and...
Episode 37 – The Watcher House
👻 Dive into the heart of darkness with Total Conundrum! 🕵️♂️ Join Jeremy and Traci as they unravel the spine-tingling tale of The Watcher House at 657 Boulevard. 💀...
Episode 36 – The Ghostly Horrors of Willowbrook Manor
👻 Prepare for a hair-raising collaboration! Join us and our fellow podcasters as we unveil the chilling tale of the ghostly horrors of Willowbrook Manor. Let’s roll out the red...
Episode 35 – Haunting in the White House
👻 Join us for a spine-tingling episode as we explore the ghosts of the White House with special guest April from Door Key Podcast! 🏛️ Discover the eerie tales...
Episode 34 – Interview with Hidden in the Shadows
Join us in our latest episode as we delve into the shadows with Megan and Issac from Hidden in the Shadows Podcast! 🌌 We explore spine-tingling tales of the...
